317-353-3000
Comparision Charts
Economy Vinyl Window Comparision (without installation)
|
Retailer Window Manufacture |
Up & Down Window 35 inches wide 71 inches tall |
Sliding Window 59 inches wide 47 inches tall |
Crank Out Window 35 inches wide 71 inches tall |
Sliding Door 72 inches wide 80 inches tall |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
ReplaceSmart Ply Gem Contactor Series |
$156.60 | $156.60 | $281.88 | $564.92 |
|
Lowe's Reliabilt by Atrium |
$198.67 | $226.06 | $336.79 | $336.00 |
|
Lowe's Pella ThermaStar Vinyl |
$216.54 | $213.87 | n/a | $583.56 |
|
Home Depot
Anderson American Craftsman 50 Series
|
$184.01 | $170.58 | $306.84 | $343.00 |
|
Menards
Crestline Select 250
|
$331.20 | $297.15 | $390.05 | $499.00 |
|
Menards
Jeld Wen Builders Vinyl
|
$254.74 | $230.98 | $361.18 | $336.00 |
|
Allied
MI Windows & Doors
|
$168.94 | $201.50 | $258.70 | $473.59 |
|
Average Savings (per window / door) |
$63.27 | $65.23 | $41.22 | n/a |
Premium Window Comparision (without installation)
|
Retailer Window Manufacture |
Up & Down Window 35 inches wide 71 inches tall |
Sliding Window 59 inches wide 47 inches tall |
Crank Out Window 35 inches wide 71 inches tall |
Sliding Door 72 inches wide 80 inches tall |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
ReplaceSmart Ply Gem Premium Series |
$276.66 | $315.52 | $370.04 | $929.74 |
|
Lowes Reliabilt by Atrium |
$316.10 | $336.78 | n/a | $718.85 |
|
Home Depot
Anderson American Craftsmen 70 Series
|
$244.84 | $278.93 | n/a | n/a |
|
Menards Crestline Select 300 |
$338.98 (Not foam filled) |
$290.15 (Not foam filled) |
$383.61 (Not foam filled) |
n/a |
|
Menards Jeld Wen Premium Vinyl |
$368.40 (Not foam filled) |
$273.19 (Not foam filled) |
$346.07 (Not foam filled) |
n/a |
|
Average Savings (per window / door) |
$168.68 | n/a | $10.40 | n/a |
* Bid included a permit costing $75 per house which equates to $18.75 per window for our 4 window bid. $18.75 was deducted from the price for an apples to apples comparison.
† Bid included tempered glass in the up and down windows only. $175 was deducted from the price for an apples to apples comparison. (Note: ReplaceSmart's price for tempered glass is $151 for same size/style window)
Plygem Premium has fiberglass reinforcement in its frame, Anderson has a composite frame. Some companies put metal in their window frames and/or sashes.
All competitive prices were collected from actual written or typed bids received from retailer by employees of ReplaceSmart between October 1, 2011 and January 31, 2012. All prices reflect the prices quoted to consumers for the listed product. All bids are for white interior and white exterior, base low-e and argon glass package with no glass dividers (grids).
None of the bids required a lead paint safe installation.
ReplaceSmart is a trademark of Clarkin Corp. All Rights Reserved. Home Depot is a registered trademark of Home Depot Inc. or their perspective owners, Lowe's is a registered trademark of Lowe's Companies Inc. or their perspective owners, Pella is a registered trademark of Pella Corporation or their perspective owners. Window World is a registered trademark of Window World Inc or their perspective owners. Simonton is a registered trademark of Simonton Windows Inc. or their perspective owners, Wincore is a registered trademark of Wincore Window Company, Llc. or their perspective owners, Sears is a registered trademark of Sears Holdings Corporation. or their perspective owners, Weatherbeater and Weatherbeater Ultra is a registered trademark of SEARS, ROEBUCK AND CO. or their perspective owners, Champion is a registered trademark of Champion Windows Manufacturing Inc. or their perspective owners, Renewal by Anderson is a registered trademark of Anderson Corporation or their perspective owners, Alside and Alside Ultramax is a registered trademark of Alside or their perspective owners, Gorell is a trademark of Softlite L.L.C. or their perspective owners. All rights are hereby disclaimed by ReplaceSmart and Clarkin Corp.
